← All ideas
  • Published 6 Jul 2020

Merge by distance should result in straight lines when it's reasonable to expect straight lines.

I can't just merge these by distance. The result is a crooked line.

I have to scale everything down to zero in Z in order for it to work. When working at an agle not aligned with a global axis I have to first make a custom axis and scale to zero before I can merge.

If merge by distance worked more sensibly it would save a lot of extra steps.

100%

Development Status: Open

Upvote 54 Downvote 0
thinsoldier
6 Jul 2020

10 Comments

bestelix

A solution to this would be to calculate the merged vertices center as it was suggested in this proposal .

The Weld modifier already has this!

3
IIIFGIII

In you case it may be predicted. In billions other possible cases it impossible to predict how this " straightiness " should look like. IMO - such thing will never be implemented...

What solve your case now - Zaloopok addon API was changed for a bit so now it give errors. Addon need update for current version. For this " Convert Edges " it need to replace 1 row to not get error. Or just remove this row if you don't want to get individual origins pivot mode each time you do this convert.

2
zelfit

* @IIIFGIII * I dont see a reason why it is not treated as a bug. I created similar model and tested in other editors. I dont understand why it cant be implemented when other software has this behavior for years. https://i.imgur.com/FQvw2rb.png

8
GabrielMoro

* @zelfit * should be treated as bug in this case indeed

Vyach

* @zelfit * in this case I use GG or M collapse or m at center. So it is possible in blender to make it.

zelfit

Accepted as TO DO and added to Medium Term developer.blender.org/T78916

1
Vyach

Average points and unselected to selected will be handy

lsscpp

Yes, upvoted. For now here's a workaround for that case: select one outer loop and slide (G+G) until the center, repeat for the other outer loop. Now Merga, without headaches

rabatin.dominik

* @ Lsscpp * you could even turn on "auto merge" before sliding the edges

1
bestelix

Good proposal! Please edit the links like below to activate direct preview.

![https://i.imgur.com/D6UzBVP.png](https://i.imgur.com/D6UzBVP.png)

A better approach in this case is to select the vertical edge rows and collapse them,