← All ideas
  • Published 19 Jun 2025

One smart command for joining vertices, instead of "F" and "J"

Currently, to connect two vertices there are two common commands:

  • F: New Edge/Face From Vertices
  • J: Connect Vertex Path (what?)

If you use F to connect vertices that are part of the same face, you'll create an edge that looks like it it splits the face, but it does not. This is almost never what what you want, and it's confusing.

CleanShot 2025-06-19 at 06.22.57.png

I propose that there should be a single command, mapped to the F key that connects vertices as expected, given the context. If someone really wants to connect two vertices with a weird floaty edge that doesn't split the face, the operator panel can offer a checkbox for that.

95.8%

Development Status: Open

Upvote 23 Downvote 1
smoothie
19 Jun 2025

3 Comments

Bill-Spitzak

Does 'J" do what you want? It might be sufficient to swap the two shortcut assignments. Though I agree, nobody wants to do what F does. If they really ,really want it, they could make the triangles, then delete both of them without deleting the edges, then select two edges of the square and hit F again, that would make the square face and leave the diagonal line uninvolved.

1

Smart idea

1
pxy-gnomes

Thoughtful. Must upgrade!

1